Skip to content

It is remarkable however how strong the power of suggestion is even in science. Max Muller's hypothetical and purely arbitrary determination of the Vedic epochs in the course of years, received more and more the dignity and the character of a scientifically proven fact, without any new arguments or actual proofs having been added.

— Moriz Winternitz

Another quote →

Source and credibility

Wikiquote does not flag this quote as disputed or misattributed.

Source: M. Winternitz, 1927:293, quoted in Chakrabarti, D. K., 1997. Colonial Indology: Sociopolitics of the Ancient Indian Past. New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd., 161.
Source quality: Secondhand citation Quoted from another book or article rather than from the original.

More by Moriz Winternitz

“Since more than 2000 years the poem of Rama has remained alive in India, and it continues to live in all strata and classes of folk. High and low, princes and peasants, landlords and artisans, princesses and shepherdesses, are well versed with the characters and stories of the great epic.”

...We shall probably have to date the beginning of this development to about 2000 or 2500 BC

Moritz, A History of Indian Literature°, vol. I, p. 288.in Danino, M (2010)

All Moriz Winternitz quotes →

More quotes by Moriz Winternitz

We cannot explain the development of the whole of this great literature if we assume as late a date as round about 1200 BC or 1500 BC as its starting-point.

As Winternitz ([1907] 1962) points out, "it is at the fixing on these purely arbitrary dates that the untenable part of Max Muller's calculations begins" (255).

I, for my part, do not understand why some Western scholars are so anxious to make the hymns of the Rgveda and the civilisation which is reflected in them so very much later than the Babylonian and Egyptian culture.

Winternitz (1907), too, hastened to note that "Max Muller himself did not really wish to say more than that such an interval at least must be assumed. . . . He always considered his date of 1200- 1000 B.C. only as a terminus ad quern" (293).

Winternitz (1907)

As regards the kinship of the languages, it is quite impossible to state definite chronological limits within which languages change. Some languages change very rapidly , others remain more or less unaltered for a long period. It is true that hieratic languages, like those of the Vedic hymns and the Avesta, can remain unaltered much longer than spoken languages.

All Moriz Winternitz quotes →

Attribution

Quote text and notes from Wikiquote: Moriz Winternitz (page history), available under CC BY-SA 4.0. Source quality and labels are our own summary of what Wikiquote records.